Oh, pizza. How we love you. Let us count the ways: Pizza makes dinner a breeze on the nights when cooking is just not gonna happen. No one in the family ever complains about pizza night, and pizza is DELICIOUS.
Pass me another slice, please.
We are lucky we have a lot of locally-owned great pizza shops in the Williamsport Area to satisfy any and all pizza cravings. Here are our 10 favorite locally-owned spots for pizza in the Williamsport Area:
1. Pudgies Pizza
Montoursville
920 Plaza Drive
Suite 1
Montoursville, PA 17754
570-980-9875
Lycoming Creek Road
2028 Lycoming Creek Road
Williamsport, PA 17701
570-322-0300
What we love: This is by far our FAVORITE spot to get pizza! WHY? It is just SO good. I can say that because I worked at a Pudgies and still LOVE to eat it! We order from Pudgies at least once a month. If you ask my kids who makes the best pizza they will respond with Pudgies! We love this place because it is family-owned, fresh, and tasty! And they have opened a second location closer to us! WIN-WIN!
2. Park Pizza
1701 Memorial Ave
Williamsport, PA 17701
(570) 322-9024
What we love: This is great pizza! We love this pizza for its 'ooey goodness, and they have great wings! The staff is AMAZING and part of the reason we love this spot. Just a heads up, this is a VERY popular place, so be prepared to wait over an hour for a pizza on their busy nights!
3. Weis Pizza
1272 E Penn St
Muncy, PA 17756
(570) 546-5472 (ask for the pizza shop)
What we love: This may not be a traditional pizza shop, but they make one of the area's BEST pizzas. We love their thin crust pizza with extra cheese or ham & pineapple. They are by far the most affordable pies in the area and taste great! You can get a thin crust, deep dish, or sheet pizza. They have wing dings and potato wedges as well to order. All their food is GREAT!
4. Basil Wood Fired Pizza
213 N Main St
Muncy, PA 17756
(570) 757-72-16
What we love: If you are looking for gourmet pizzas, this is the spot to get one! This is an ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL place to dine and enjoy a pizza. Their pizza is wood-fired (hence their name) and tastes AMAZING! They also have wood-fired wings and the BEST truffle fries. If you have never tried truffle fries, you need to! This is a great place for a dinner date or a family night out!
5. Joe's Pizza East End
1810 Northway Rd
Williamsport, PA 17701
(570) 322-6871 or (570) 322-7871
967 West 3rd Street
Williamsport, PA 17701
(570) 326-2121 or (570) 326-2133
What we love: Located on Northway Road, this pizza shop is another of our favorites. Their pizza is fresh and hot and ready to eat. We love the family-friendly atmosphere and how accommodating they are for their customers. They will cut the pizza into smaller sizes or bite-size bites for even the littlest of customers! This is great, authentic pizza and great stromboli. They have two locations to serve you better!
6. Leo's Pizzeria
458 William Street
Williamsport, PA 17702
(272) 202-3803
What we love: Leo's Pizzeria is great. They have great customer service and they are always accommodating. They are always coming up with unique and new tasting pies. Our favorite is Fried BBQ Chicken pie! Pizza is not the only thing they serve here. They have great sandwiches as well.
7. La Casa de Pizza/House of Pizza
524 Market Street
Lewisburg, PA 17837
(570) 523-9333
What we love: This is our FAVORITE place to get pizza if we are near or around Lewisburg. If you want to try a great pie, get it here! Their pizza is always hot and gooey good! If you ask my kids what their favorite pizza is in Lewisburg, they will tell you House of Pizza! Great service and the owners and employees are very accommodating. We love their cheese pizza!
8. Unida Pizza
1599 Montour Blvd.
Danville, PA 17821
(570) 275-6466
What we love: This is my husband's favorite spot to get pizza. It is his go-to for ordering pizza for his workers or when someone asks him where to get pizza from. Unida Pizza's name speaks for itself, am I right? Who doesn't need a pizza! The pizza is always fresh and hot. It tastes good reheated or even eaten cold (come on you know you still eat cold pizza from time to time). The service is great and the staff is friendly! They offer catering and office lunches!
9. Pizza King
226 East Main Street
Lock Haven, PA 17745
(570) 748-5220
What we love: Pizza King is Lock Haven's favorite family-owned pizza shop, take out or delivery. They have a variety of toppings and offer medium and large hand-tossed pies and stromboli's to go. We have never personally tried this place, but my good friend said all they make is pizza so they are great at it! Definitely a place we will have to try when we are up that way!
10. Venice Pizza Shop
1875 E 3rd Street
Williamsport, PA 17701
(570) 327-8667
What we love: Venice Pizza is AMAZING pizza and needed to be on this list! This was a favorite of mine in my teen years and is still a family staple. They have great cosmos and much more! People travel from as far as State College to enjoy their pizza pie! Hands down, this is a must to try in the area.
